Verify Citation - 5. Music, Temperament, and Social Concord

From The Observatory
The Creation of Order »  Query: 5. Music, Temperament, and Social Concord

Verify Citation

Quoted text:

“The interval CE in Pythagorean tuning gives a C that is too low, an E that is too high: hence Clotho’s and Atropos’s adjustments. Lachesis’s task is to make A♭ and G♯ coincide, adjusting one with each hand. ‘Plato saw the necessity of temperament for systems meant to function in harmony, be they musical scales, planetary orbits, or communities of just men’” (Godwin 1983: pp. 298f., quoting McClain[1] 1977: p. 55).

We could find McClain (the quotation within the quotation) and cite it, but we could not find “Godwin 1983.” Can you help us find the text and a full citation that we can add as a footnote and bibliographical note? It might be related to Cosmic Music, edited by Joscelyn Godwin; however, the edition we found is dated 1989 (not 1983 as written here) and doesn’t have enough total pages to merit the citation here of pp. 298f., so it seems unlikely to be the one.

Verify, build on, or correct the text as written. Join the research!
  1. Ernest G. McClain, The Pythagorean Plato: Prelude to the Song Itself (Maine: 1978), p. 55.