Info:93cbb2e1-37d3-481b-9c03-681525047f28

Query: 5. Music, Temperament, and Social Concord{{Article buttons|override=The Creation of Order/Summer: Balancing Self-Expression With Group Order/5. Music, Temperament, and Social Concord|DeepArea=The Creation of Order/Summer: Balancing Self-Expression With Group Order/5. Music, Temperament, and Social Concord}}
{{#widget:copy uuid}} Return to the Host Page

Omitted Text

Quoted text:

Social Setting for Art

[Omitted text:]

From “art” and “armos” comes “arete,” “virtue.” The superlative “aristos” (“fittest,” “best”) now connotes the doctrine of survival of the fittest.


I began this chapter with a quotation from Aristotle distinguishing high culture from barbarism. Let us return to his argument, for at this very moment in time an ossification was setting in. Art was becoming bourgeois.

[/End of omitted text]

Aristotle (Politics VIII.3 at 1337b) stated that high culture required leisure time for contemplation, and hence wealth (much as to be a member of the aristocratic cavalry, one needed enough wealth to spend one’s time training with one’s horse). But there also was a danger here: The ruling class might become conservative.

There was omitted text here that was a stub. Would you like to help us expand it so we can add it back to the Chapter 5 body?

Note: The “quotation from Aristotle” was most likely:

“The poets do not depict Zeus as playing the lyre and singing in person,” pointed out Aristotle[1] (1339b). “In fact we call the performers ‘technicians’ and think that a man should not perform except for his own amusement or when he has had a good deal to drink.” Thus, like his contemporaries, Aristotle dismissed musicianship as being a mere craft (“techne”), and as such, unbecoming to men of leisure.

Suggest an edit or addition for this query. Join the research!
  1. ↑ Aristotle, Politics, Book 8, section 1339b.